On international students
I just came across a forum post where a chinese student referred to the existence of singaporeans as safety nets during the finals. Looking at the comments posted in reaction to his statement, I can't help but feel that many singaporeans are incredibly myopic when it comes to matters like this.
Granted that remark was insensitive, inconsiderate, and above all else inadmissable for a foreigner to make of his host country, no matter how true it may be. The truth is that, when I studied in NUS I thought that way as well, that there were always the lazy ass types who would cushion my fall, if ever. It just happened to be a coincidence that many of these lazy ass types were people with whom I shared the same nationality. That said, while it may be permissible for me to say it (since I'm Singaporean I'm entitled to badmouth my own countrymen lol), it is not for him, and it just reflects how lowly this particular chinese regards Singapore and her students.
However, on the flip side of the coin, I just wonder, how well has NUS welcomed foreigners? How well has NUS succeeded in integrating foreign students into Singapore? It is weird how Singaporeans take it for granted that foreigners must be able to speak perfect English when they themselves can't even get basic grammar right. Comments such as "let's give them a paper for every module and see if they can still score or not" just reflect this double standard with regards to foreigners. I admit that English is a language which must be mastered before going overseas for anybody. Yet it is completely impossible given the circumstances in which many of these students live before going overseas. Let me ask this of any Singaporean: How well have you mastered your second language, be it Chinese or Malay or Tamil or even English? How fluently can you speak it?
In all my encounters with Singaporeans, there has been but a mere minority who can use both languages with ease. Let me throw a typical Singaporean chinese into a chinese-learning environment. Do you think he will not struggle, not have any problems adapting whatsoever?
My thoughts, of course, come from my own personal experience as a foreign student in a foreign university, immersed in a foreign language environment. Here in France, all the classes are taught in French. We are expected to argue, converse, and communicate in French. It hardly needs to be said that French is nowhere near my first nor my second language. Nor is it for many foreign students here. What warms my heart, however, is how the Direction des Etudes takes into account the difficulty foreign students have with the language, and gives us some leeway when it comes to difficult stuff such as papers. When I heard that my paper for a sociology module would be marked on a different grading scheme than that for French students, I was at once grateful and hurt at the same time. I was indignant that they "underestimate" my/our level of French, yet at the same time grateful because I know that my French sucks. Why is this not done for foreign students in NUS?
Studying here in France is a rare chance to step outside the suffocating confines of NUS to look at a bigger picture of the world. Here I use all 3 languages that I know on a daily basis, and I have made enormous progress with my Chinese and my French. I mix with Chinese whom I have found to be warm and nice, albeit sometimes closed off within their community. I have discovered a different world which, in NUS, I never bothered to find out, despite the high percentage of Chinese in the school. I now realize that I, in Singapore, was just like the French students here now where I study. I had not thought to open myself to the international crowd. I had stayed contentedly within my comfort zone, and alienated foreign students because it was simply just easier to lay all the blame on them.
Which is incredibly myopic, that I have realized now.
That said, there is no excuse for making a remark like that. However, I think it is time to start bridging this gap of mutual distrust before it all culminates in some kind of violent earth-shaking nationalist movement. Conflict happens all the time with anybody in an international setting. As Singaporeans, as citizens of a global city, where foreigners and tourists alike come to at incredibly high numbers, there is no space for intolerance and distrust. This is honestly compounded by the fact that foreign students who take up the tuition loan have a 3 year bond to serve in Singapore, so don't expect the 1/3 foreign population to disappear anytime soon.
And yeah we can all blame the government for having made the wrong decisions.
Now I know that I have completely sidestepped the original topic at hand. I have already made my stand with regards to that however. I just want to say that in Singapore we take a very dim view of foreigners who do not speak "proper" English, and we brandish that as evidence that they do not wish to integrate into our society. We do not step into their shoes and see matters from their point of view, that in fact any non-mother tongue language takes time to master. I am highly aware that I live in a contradictory country, where my countrymen have distinctly different realities from the reality of the world around them. I am conscient of the fact that our government itself implements contradictory policies from time to time, and which promotes a constructed environment of "meritocracy" which stifles other kinds of merits from surfacing. I know too that matters such as these are rarely, if ever, black and white, that there are many things to consider before making a judgment of any kind.
I know full well too that comments on facebook represent but a small minority, but who are part of the younger generation of Singapore who will make up the bulk of the working class in the near future. Who will feel the effects of the foreign policy keenly in the coming years. Whose comments however may have been made in a rare rush of recklessness, which may not truly reflect their opinions.
Let me just say that in whichever case, our tiny island is like a prison more than anything else. Take a hard look at the world around it, and perhaps more Singaporeans would realize that Singapore is actually not at the centre of the world.
Far from it, really.
Granted that remark was insensitive, inconsiderate, and above all else inadmissable for a foreigner to make of his host country, no matter how true it may be. The truth is that, when I studied in NUS I thought that way as well, that there were always the lazy ass types who would cushion my fall, if ever. It just happened to be a coincidence that many of these lazy ass types were people with whom I shared the same nationality. That said, while it may be permissible for me to say it (since I'm Singaporean I'm entitled to badmouth my own countrymen lol), it is not for him, and it just reflects how lowly this particular chinese regards Singapore and her students.
However, on the flip side of the coin, I just wonder, how well has NUS welcomed foreigners? How well has NUS succeeded in integrating foreign students into Singapore? It is weird how Singaporeans take it for granted that foreigners must be able to speak perfect English when they themselves can't even get basic grammar right. Comments such as "let's give them a paper for every module and see if they can still score or not" just reflect this double standard with regards to foreigners. I admit that English is a language which must be mastered before going overseas for anybody. Yet it is completely impossible given the circumstances in which many of these students live before going overseas. Let me ask this of any Singaporean: How well have you mastered your second language, be it Chinese or Malay or Tamil or even English? How fluently can you speak it?
In all my encounters with Singaporeans, there has been but a mere minority who can use both languages with ease. Let me throw a typical Singaporean chinese into a chinese-learning environment. Do you think he will not struggle, not have any problems adapting whatsoever?
My thoughts, of course, come from my own personal experience as a foreign student in a foreign university, immersed in a foreign language environment. Here in France, all the classes are taught in French. We are expected to argue, converse, and communicate in French. It hardly needs to be said that French is nowhere near my first nor my second language. Nor is it for many foreign students here. What warms my heart, however, is how the Direction des Etudes takes into account the difficulty foreign students have with the language, and gives us some leeway when it comes to difficult stuff such as papers. When I heard that my paper for a sociology module would be marked on a different grading scheme than that for French students, I was at once grateful and hurt at the same time. I was indignant that they "underestimate" my/our level of French, yet at the same time grateful because I know that my French sucks. Why is this not done for foreign students in NUS?
Studying here in France is a rare chance to step outside the suffocating confines of NUS to look at a bigger picture of the world. Here I use all 3 languages that I know on a daily basis, and I have made enormous progress with my Chinese and my French. I mix with Chinese whom I have found to be warm and nice, albeit sometimes closed off within their community. I have discovered a different world which, in NUS, I never bothered to find out, despite the high percentage of Chinese in the school. I now realize that I, in Singapore, was just like the French students here now where I study. I had not thought to open myself to the international crowd. I had stayed contentedly within my comfort zone, and alienated foreign students because it was simply just easier to lay all the blame on them.
Which is incredibly myopic, that I have realized now.
That said, there is no excuse for making a remark like that. However, I think it is time to start bridging this gap of mutual distrust before it all culminates in some kind of violent earth-shaking nationalist movement. Conflict happens all the time with anybody in an international setting. As Singaporeans, as citizens of a global city, where foreigners and tourists alike come to at incredibly high numbers, there is no space for intolerance and distrust. This is honestly compounded by the fact that foreign students who take up the tuition loan have a 3 year bond to serve in Singapore, so don't expect the 1/3 foreign population to disappear anytime soon.
And yeah we can all blame the government for having made the wrong decisions.
Now I know that I have completely sidestepped the original topic at hand. I have already made my stand with regards to that however. I just want to say that in Singapore we take a very dim view of foreigners who do not speak "proper" English, and we brandish that as evidence that they do not wish to integrate into our society. We do not step into their shoes and see matters from their point of view, that in fact any non-mother tongue language takes time to master. I am highly aware that I live in a contradictory country, where my countrymen have distinctly different realities from the reality of the world around them. I am conscient of the fact that our government itself implements contradictory policies from time to time, and which promotes a constructed environment of "meritocracy" which stifles other kinds of merits from surfacing. I know too that matters such as these are rarely, if ever, black and white, that there are many things to consider before making a judgment of any kind.
I know full well too that comments on facebook represent but a small minority, but who are part of the younger generation of Singapore who will make up the bulk of the working class in the near future. Who will feel the effects of the foreign policy keenly in the coming years. Whose comments however may have been made in a rare rush of recklessness, which may not truly reflect their opinions.
Let me just say that in whichever case, our tiny island is like a prison more than anything else. Take a hard look at the world around it, and perhaps more Singaporeans would realize that Singapore is actually not at the centre of the world.
Far from it, really.
